Insurance Companies, Claims & Bill Payments

At Yoder Insurance Inc we are pleased to represent the full array of insurance products and services from the following highly-rated companies.

Available within these listings you are likely to see direct links to each carrier’s primary website, online bill payment integration, claim submissions and company-direct telephone information for additional policy service and support.




Aegis

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-233-2160

Agency Insurance Company

Company:

Website

Claims/Service: 800-841-5241
   

 

 

Nationwide

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-421-3535

AmTrust Financial

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

866-272-9267

ASI Progressive

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service: 866-274-5677

Briar Creek Mutual

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

N/A

Claims/Service:

Call Your Agent

CNA Surety

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

877-672-6115

Donegal Insurance Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-877-9006

Encompass

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-588-7400

Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

877-467-2252

Hagerty

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-922-4050
option #5

Millville Mutual Insurance Company

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-262-8495

Montour Mutual

Claims/Service:

570-275-0221

Mutual Benefit Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-290-6361

Progressive Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-776-4737

Reamstown Mutual Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

1-888-764-7232

State Auto Insurance Companies

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-766-1853
Glass Only: 888-504-4527

Travelers

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

Personal: 800-252-4633
Commercial: 800-238-6225